Monday, April 29, 2013

Deliverance vs Arrogance





IF YOU WERE A SLAVE OR A FREED SLAVE WOULD IT BE LOGICAL TO ATTACK AND REJECT THOSE WHO CONSTANTLY PRAYED AND WORKED FOR YOUR FREEDOM?

4/29/2013
Several years ago I had a conversation with an inmate in the Georgia Prisons System who had fallen under the influence of the Chinese House Church founders named WATCHMAN NEE and WITNESS LEE.  I think this is probably the only reason I know who these people are. Witness Lee, actually created the "house church movement" based upon the work of his mentor, Watchman Nee. Watchman Nee owned and worked in a factory in pre-communist China, from what I gather was never a "religious figure" of that time.   The House Church Movement (an underground Christian movement) in communist China is logical. However in its expression in the West and in freer China has of course already splintered into muti-groups and associations and some of them have become very radical.  But the hallmark of all of them is the violent and dogmatic rejection of the Visible (or as they say Institutional) Church, believing that their theological presumptions are absolute truth, and that all realty of THE CHURCH in the free world, the great witness and deposit of the Faith, outside their particular experience is false. They believe there are other Christians, but that no Visible Church upon the earth is truly an expression of The Apostolic Church against which the gates of hell have not prevailed since the time of the Apostles. For them such a prospect, though visibly present, is impossible.

Watchman Nee wrote over one hundred massive volumes of convoluted theology, sixty some odd refined and published in English. His writings brim with an overt spiritualism that is overwhelming page to page. The sheer volume of writing dwarfs the collective writings of the Eastern Saints, known as the Philokalia. It makes prolific Church writers like Origen and Saint Thomas Aquinas look virtually mute.  In his isolated spirituality, creating his own form of Christian belief in pre-communist China he had limited resources and few influences, none that represented the fullness of The Faith once and for all Delivered unto the Saint which is contained in the Church. He like so many cobbled together "a Gospel" not the completeness of "The Gospel." 

Those who experience the presence of the Holy Spirit in prison, are foolish to reject those who have held HIS presence in freedom. For freedom is not Liberty, but rather the furnace of the tempter, where one is able to chose right and wrong in a casual way. Right and Wrong decisions in prison are clearer, and the choices more striking as to what is LIFE producing and what is Death producing.  In "prison states" where Secular States have taken control of Church administrations, like in China, and previously in Russia, the integrity of the institution has to be viewed with suspicion. Even today there are problems with the close ties between some national governments and national Churches. You can't become a successor to the Apostles (a bishop) by killing a Bishop or by a secular government appointing a bishop. But despite the Church's institutional failings her apostolic reality remains. When those Christians who have experienced persecution, who when free turn on those who have maintained the Church in Liberty, it shows a real form of insanity, a post-persecution syndrome, unable to respond to the prayers and works that have helped saved them.

Here is a demonstration of this spirit in a young oriental man, certain that the apostolic church is evil. 



A Ug
Okay, so how is the Greek Orthodox Church different from the Roman Catholic Church? and how so?

11:16pm
Piano Butch Robinson
It would take a book to explain it to you and still you would not understand it, since you have no experience of it. Or do you? Have you had experience of the Roman Catholic Church?

11:17pm
A Ug
Why wouldn't I understand?

11:18pm
Piano Butch Robinson
Answer the question. Have you had experience of the Roman Catholic Church?

11:19pm
A Ug
I attend a Franciscan University...so I have some familiarity with the Roman Catholic Church.

11:21pm
Piano Butch Robinson
So you are not catholic, have never studied the foundations of the Apostolic Church, have spent some time listening to . . . I'm guessing . . . assembly of God or sum such preachers and because you attend a quasi-catholic institution you think you have an understanding of the experience of God in Jesus Christ present in HIS church???

11:24pm
A Ug
I know that I have the experience of knowing Christ. In brother Yun's book, "The Heavenly Man," God was impacting lives in I believe the south-west Chinese area where people were living off of knowing Jesus soley through the Scriptures. Miracles were happening and everything. Then, when various Christian literature and doctrine other than the Bible was incorporated amongst the sola scripture congregation, the body of Christ suffered a huge division. I haven't read the book for a summer, but it is an amazing book...so yes, I am certain.

11:31pm
A Ug
Keep guessing. I do not attend a Assembly of God church. No, I don't trust in an institution. I trust in Christ.

11:33pm
Piano Butch Robinson
I know many people who came to Christ through the scriptures, but when faced with the reality of the physical presence of Christ's Body the Church upon the earth, didn't reject Christ's Bride, rather entered into deeper faith; Just as Cornelius and his household had already received the Baptism of the Holy Spirit, but did not reject the Baptism of the Apostles and entry into the visible and apostolic church. There is a sea of "literature" out there - most of it Protestant. But the fullness of the Faith is held in Christ's Church, where HE, Himself breathed the Holy Spirit upon its founders and promised that the gates of hell would not prevail against her. That Church is "apostolic" and not "institutional".

11:35pm
A Ug
I was going to share a silly experience I had. But, I have like 20 minutes to complete this paper.

11:36pm
Piano Butch Robinson
I understand. I'm going to link a paper I want you to read when you have time. Since you are intelligent and already forming theological ideas. It is about the methods of forming those ideas.

11:38pm
Piano Butch Robinson
I wrote this decades ago, but it will give us an framework - maybe even a language to talk in the future.

America's Orthodox Christian Chaplain: The Three Paths of Theology/Spirituality
americaschaplain.blogspot.com

12:13am
Piano Butch Robinson
Adron, I saw that you are into music. Me too. Here is one of several recordings I made a few years back. I love to write music. I have two jazz pieces and another semi-classical piece ready to record, and hope I get to before the Lord calls me home.

Elise Fantasia - Bond Robin Pianist, Composer
www.youtube.com
Takeoff on a theme by Beethoven, written by Bond Robin (aka, Piano Butch, aka Marion Robinson).

12:25am
A Ug
Well, I have to say that your post is really heavy. Good research!

12:29am
Piano Butch Robinson
I read a short bio of Brother Yun's life - a wonderful testimony of the presence of the Holy Spirit, witnessing the reality of Jesus Christ in Atheistic China. God's hand is not shortened. Here is what the Church says about such people:
"Inasmuch as the earthly and visible Church is not the fullness and completeness of the whole Church which the Lord has appointed to appear at the final judgment of all creation, she acts and knows only within her own limits; and (according to the words of Paul the Apostle, to the Corinthians, 1 Cor. 5. 12) does not judge the rest of mankind, and only looks upon those as excluded, that is to say, not belonging to her, who exclude themselves."
Be careful Adron, that in your limited understanding of the reality of Christ's Body upon the earth that you do not "exclude yourself."

12:31am
A Ug
Are you implying that I need to be a part of a certain denomination to be a part of the body of Christ? As long as I am serving Christ, I am in Christ.

12:32am
Piano Butch Robinson
The Church knows nothing of Denominations - that is protestant ignorance.

12:33am
A Ug
Like I have to be a part of an Orthodox church? I know that I can't be a part of the Roman Orthodox Church. I just can't do it. I'll look into int and I'll read your articles, but people like Brother Yun are certainly not excluded from Christ.

12:33am
Piano Butch Robinson

Letters From the Gulag : What is the Church?

lettersfromthegulag.blogspot.com

12:34am
Piano Butch Robinson
Adron, WHY are you so defensive?

12:34am
A Ug
You're implying that I'm excluded from Christ. Read your last sentence.

12:35am
Piano Butch Robinson
He could be excluded from the Body and you could be too, IF you actively reject the real and visible presence of Christ's Body - present with Apostolic reality from the very beginning.

12:36am
A Ug
Haven't you read Acts 11:1-18. If Christ's Holy Spirit is working in you, then you are saved. His Spirit is working in me.

12:37am
Piano Butch Robinson
What do you think would have happened to Cornelius if he had refused the Baptism of Peter? Acts 10:7 ff

12:37am
A Ug
How could Brother Yun be excluded from the body of Christ and still have Christ working through His life Sola Scripture. You are making no sense.
Another Disciple would have baptized him.
It's not Peter alone.

12:42am
Piano Butch Robinson
By Peter I mean the WHOLE of Apostolic ministry. IF he rejected Peter's Baptism WHY would he have accepted any of the other founders of the Church Visible upon the earth? AS to Christ rejecting Yun?
Have you not read of the day of Judgement when preachers will say, "But Lord, I preformed miracles in your name, I cast out demons in your name, I healed the sick." And the Lord says, "Depart from me, etc." ????? Surely you know the scripture. It is a miracle of GRACE when the Holy Spirit honors the Baptism of a women left lost in an atheist country, who revives her faith and prays and raises her sick husband, and impart faith into her son. But were that Son to arrive before the successors of the Apostles and reject them - that is another story.

12:45am
A Ug
Tell me plainly what your view of salvation is. How inclusive is it? How much of it is of Christ and how much of it is of this church you call the TRUE CHURCH.

12:45am
Piano Butch Robinson
You speak error trying to separate Christ from his own body.

12:46am
A Ug
Come again?

12:46am
Piano Butch Robinson
THINK - PRAY and TRY to grasp what I am saying.

12:49am
A Ug
Here's what you need to understand. This needs no commentary. Think it over:
11 For it hath been declared unto me of you, my brethren, by them which are of the house of Chloe, that there are contentions among you.
12 Now this I say, that every one of you saith, I am of Paul; and I of Apollos; and I of Cephas; and I of Christ.
13 Is Christ divided? was Paul crucified for you? or were ye baptized in the name of Paul?
14 I thank God that I baptized none of you, but Crispus and Gaius;
15 Lest any should say that I had baptized in mine own name.
16 And I baptized also the household of Stephanas: besides, I know not whether I baptized any other.
17 For Christ sent me not to baptize, but to preach the gospel: not with wisdom of words, lest the cross of Christ should be made of none effect" (1 Corinthians 1:11-17)
I know that I am not wrong. I am willing to bet my life on it.

12:50am
A Ug
Cephas is one of St. Peter's names.

12:50am
Piano Butch Robinson
Adron, The Church visible IS Christ Body (not the totality of it) but with certainty CHRIST's Body. You talk of salvation as if it can exist outside of Christ's Body? Can you please show me the text where this is possible? In that scripture you sight ALL are apostle or successors of apostles. NONE are radical independent spiritualist.

12:52am
A Ug
I have never stated that you are not a part of Christ's body, but you seem to believe that I am not a part of Christ's body because I am not baptized into St. Peter's successorship. God's Scripture is right in front of your face and you are rejecting it. How dare you!?

12:55am
Piano Butch Robinson
You are hung up on "peter's succession" ignoring the rest of the Apostles upon which Christ gave the governance of the Church, with such power and authority -
Joh 20:19 Then, the same day at evening, being the first day of the week, when the doors were shut where the disciples were assembled, for fear of the Jews, Jesus came and stood in the midst, and said to them, "Peace to you."
Joh 20:20 And having said this, He showed them His hands and His side. Then the disciples rejoiced when they saw the Lord.
Joh 20:21 Therefore Jesus said to them again, "Peace to you! Just as the Father has sent Me, I also send you."
Joh 20:22 And when He had said this, He breathed on them, and said to them, "Receive the Holy Spirit.
Joh 20:23 If you forgive the sins of any, they are forgiven them; if you retain the sins of any, they have been retained."

12:57am
A Ug
Consider this:
"And said unto them, Whosoever shall receive this child in my name receiveth me: and whosoever shall receive me receiveth him that sent me: for he that is least among you all, the same shall be great.
49 And John answered and said, Master, we saw one casting out devils in thy name; and we forbad him, because he followeth not with us.
50 And Jesus said unto him, Forbid him not: for he that is not against us is for us" (Luke 9:48-50)
Careful surface level analysis of the text reveals that Jesus Christ does not believe that this random dude is not a part of His body of believers. Delving deep into the text reveals the same thing.

1:00am
Piano Butch Robinson
I am a minister in apostolic succession where from my head to Jesus Christ's hand may be traced only one hundred and forty four people across two thousand years of time. ALL preaching the same gospel, holding the same faith, exercising the same authority in Christ's body the Church. Do you reject this?

1:01am
A Ug
No. have you read the documents of your 112th person in your precession? How do you know that you are teaching EXACTLY the same as him?

1:02am
Piano Butch Robinson
Have you not read the scriptures? Do you not know the writing of the Holy Father's of all the centuries? Are you ignorant of the Traditions of the Apostles held and practiced for these many years?

1:02am
A Ug
I asked you a question that you are not answering.

1:03am
Piano Butch Robinson
The simple answer is, YES you are ignorant.

1:03am
A Ug
Such kind words

1:03am
Piano Butch Robinson
Ignorance isn't a slur, it is a condition.

1:04am
A Ug
Well then, thank you for diagnosing me.
I have one more question for you. Will you accept it.

1:05am
Piano Butch Robinson
Ignorance - lack of knowledge, training, or the like.
Ask away

1:05am
A Ug
I didn't ask for a definition to ignorance.
This is the condition:

1:05am
Piano Butch Robinson
You seemed to need it since you seem to think it was a slur
How old are you, Adron?

1:06am
A Ug
Excuse me, I'm asking a question, am I not?
Why does it matter?
I never asked you and you said that I could ask the questions. So let me!

1:07am
Piano Butch Robinson
Yes, You debate me, with little respect for a elder, contrary to scripture, with arrogance and ego from the beginning on my timeline? Yes, it matters.

1:08am
A Ug
You interrupted me. Paul would wait for a response and then answer back. It was not his custom to interrupt people. I don't even think that you want to hear my question.

1:08am
Piano Butch Robinson
How old are you? What have you experience in life? How has YOUR faith been tested? Have YOU place your life in danger for your love of Christ?
So you know the soul and personality of SAINT Paul - does your ego have no limit?
Please - I am not silent before my master - Adron. Continue.

1:11am
A Ug
Stop interrupting me. You are only judging me based upon status. John never listed how old Gaius was in the Third Letter of John, so why is it so important that you know?
I've read Acts. I know how he spoke in Athens. I analyzed the situation. But, no, I do not personally know the Apostle Paul and neither do you.

1:16am
Piano Butch Robinson
I know enough of Saint Paul that he didn't suffer fools well and when he faced those pretending to be "of the Church" with no true connection except their PRIDE he called them mockingly "super-apostles." So you must be a super-saint, in your two decades of living comprehending and experiencing more than me in my seven decades of living. When YOU place your body - your physical LIFE in real danger for your love of Jesus Christ, contact me and tell me about it. Until then, what you say is merely theory.

1:18am
Piano Butch Robinson
2Co 12:11 I have become a fool in boasting; you have compelled me! For I ought to have been commended by you; for in nothing have I been inferior to the super apostles, though I am nothing.

1:18am
A Ug
Jesus clearly states that we are not to call people, "fools," (Matthew 5:22), but you are implying that I am one. Why??

1:19am
Piano Butch Robinson
Opps you were a little late. You arrogant young person.
Are you a fool in your youthful arrogance? That is self evident. One cannot learn when one is convinced that one already holds full knowledge.

1:21am
A Ug
Why do I get the impression that the more we respond, the more you type devoid of the love of God. I never called you a fool or an arrogant one. Now, I'm afraid that you will type more loveless things.
You haven't convinced me of anything. But, I have been considering your arguments. You started out this discussion calling me an intellectual...and now you have totally swayed---because I have differing beliefs.
You have more-so insulted me than anything, as of lately.
[This discussion is over. If you really want the last word, then you can have it. But, I will not be responding...simple as that]

1:26am
Piano Butch Robinson
THINK Adron, a Tradition of only one hundred and forty four people - a number that could sit together in a very small chapel. THIS is my heritage and it is a heritage connected with the Holy Spirit. Because I challenge your self-satisfied theology you are increasingly temped to call me "demonic." You are not demonic, just humanly arrogant, thinking that your Chinese master is the POPE.
BTW intelligence and WISDOM are NOT synonymous.

1:26am
Piano Butch Robinson
Are you frightened to face the truth?

1:29am
A Ug
I am not frightened at all. I have noticed that you think that I am calling you, "demonic." I never said that!!! I never called Brother Yun a Pope, either.
You are really good at setting up "straw-man" arguments. That is a skill that you should not be proud of. The Apostle Paul was skilled in Rhetoric and other disciplines, so he would understand.
[But now the discussion is over. I don't want to see any more straw-man arguments, where you insult me...without analyzing my case. Stop it!]

1:30am
Piano Butch Robinson
Do you know the definitions of hyperbole?

1:34am
Piano Butch Robinson
So I use the hyperbolic terms "demonic" and "Pope" and in fear you resign the field? Where is your courage, Man? If the Holy Spirit guides your thoughts or mine, let us discover it, NOW. One of us is in error, holding the understanding of Christ Body the Church in a truncated form. And one of us is not in error. Why resign the field before the answer is clear?


  • A Ug

    Well, now you have a new article. Congratulations! Do you do this with all your facebook conversations for publicity? And I resign, at least for now because it is too late...or should I say early
  • Piano Butch Robinson

    Adron, who are you kidding? YOU resigned the conversation, not me. I merely took from it what my experience had taught me. This is certain . . . you Chinese who think that your experience of Christ's intervention in your slavery is unique and un-connected to the apostolic reality - need to think again and find some humility.
  • A Ug

    Maybe with it being 3:04 A.M, I am a little bit tired now, okay. Yet, you'll post the rest of this conversation anyway without my consent...or maybe you won't so that it will appear on your blog as if you had my consent? Whatever the case, why should I care...anyway/anymore?

    Piano Butch Robinson

    Adron, Corey Ten Boom was a personal friend of mine. I am not unaware of extreme sacrifice under the oppression of Godless authority. Her friend in prison was, Mother Maria of Paris, who I spent decades assuring her recognition as saint. You talk to me of arrogant individualized spirituality and theology - as if the inspiration of those oppressed represents clear theology. I talk to you with the wisdom of those who have sacrificed all. Mother Maria of Paris, a Russian Orthodox Nun, stepped into the line of those heading to the gas chambers in NAZI Germany, took the place of a young woman heading to her death. Mother Maria saved a whore - collaborator with the Germans and a German's bastard child. ALL your talk is theory and self satisfied theologies - where your reading of TEXTS - WE GAVE TO YOU -  is supreme. And the source of that TEXT means nothing. In this you ARE arrogant and a fool.

1 comment: